Every day, through scorching summers and chilly winters, Himmat pedals his bicycle rickshaw through New Delhi's crowded streets, earning barely enough to feed his family. But to India's government he is not poor — not even close.
The 5,000 rupees ($110) he earns a month pays for a tiny room with a single light bulb and no running water for his family of four. After buying just enough food to keep his family from starving, there is nothing left for medicine, new clothes for his children or savings.
Still, Himmat is way above India's poverty line.
Earlier this month, India's Planning Commission, which helps sets economic policy, told the Supreme Court that the poverty line for the nation's cities was 578 rupees ($12.75) per person a month — or 2,312 rupees ($51.38) for Himmat's family of four. For rural India, it's even lower at about 450 rupees ($9.93).
The revelation set off an angry debate in a country with soaring economic growth that has brought Ferrari dealerships and Louis Vuitton stores to cater to the new urban rich but left hundreds of millions of others struggling without access to adequate food and clean water.
The World Bank global poverty line, at $1.25 a day or about $38 per month, is three times higher than India's urban level. Local activists say a better name for India's standard would be "the starvation line."
"This number is a joke. There's no seriousness about the poor," activist Aruna Roy said.
The Planning Commission said it has to set the poverty line — which determines who gets government assistance — to make the best use of limited funds.
"When you have such a large number of people, given the resources that are available to the government, do you target the poorest of the poor or do you spread your net wider and succeed in covering nobody?" Pranab Sen, an adviser to the Planning Commission, recently told the NDTV news channel.
A daily allowance of 19 rupees (42 cents) would buy 3 1/2 bananas from a stall outside the commission's own office in the Indian capital or less than two pounds (one kilogram) of wheat flour or rice, staples for most Indians.
Himmat, who like many Indians uses just one name, said India's poverty line was ridiculous.
"What can we eat with that much money? Not even two dry rotis," he said, referring to the traditional flat bread of north India.
Rent for his room, which is no larger than 10 feet by 4 feet, costs 1,500 rupees ($33). He struggles to send his two children to a poorly run government school that costs him another 1,000 rupees ($22). The remaining 2,500 ($55) must pay for food, medicines and any other necessities for his family.
In the summer, he sends his wife and children back to their village in eastern India and sleeps on the sidewalk to save on rent.
"I am a very poor man. I can't imagine living on any less money," he said.
The poverty debate began after India's top court asked the Planning Commission to explain earlier this month why hundreds of millions of Indians are undernourished when the country had vast stores of food grains — at times running into millions of tons of surplus.
The commission maintained the government has only limited resources to distribute the grain to subsidized shops, and that it must set its poverty line accordingly to target the neediest.
Rights activists and some economists have slammed the commission, saying it should guide the government to set aside adequate resources to help the poor, and not merely set a poverty line so low that hundreds of millions are kept out of the social security net.
"In a globalized economy why are the people of India naked? It's because the planning is to keep them naked," said activist and lawyer Colin Gonsalves.
Dozens of activists protested outside the commission's office earlier this week carrying small cardboard gift boxes for its members. The boxes contained the cheapest bus ticket, a pound (about 500 grams) of the cheapest rice, one potato, one onion, one banana, a matchbox and a pencil and overshot the daily budget by two rupees (4 cents).
"I propose that the Planning Commission members do their own research for one day. If they can live on this money and tell us how they did it we will stop protesting," said activist Nikhil Dey.
For most of the last six decades since gaining independence from British rule, India has struggled to find a method to identify its poor and provide for them, at times trying to count calorie intake and now using income data that economists acknowledge are unreliable.
Using the commission's poverty line, 37 percent of India's 1.2 billion people qualify as poor.
The country currently spends 2 percent of its GDP — about 29 billion — in social protection, and half of that goes to the Public Distribution System, which provides the poor with subsidized food. Even with the low poverty line, the system — riddled with corruption and mismanagement — caters to over 440 million people, more than the entire population of the United States.
The World Bank poverty line would add about 60 million more people to that category.
Critics say even that is too few, and that India needs to extend its social security net to hundreds of millions more who like Himmat, the rickshaw puller, live in penury.
The Planning Commission's current approach implies that the coverage of social benefits will shrink if not disappear over time, said Jean Dreze, a development economist affiliated with the Delhi School of Economics.
"In a rapidly growing economy, one would like to see the opposite," he said.
For Himmat, who is illiterate and oblivious to what he can expect from the government, the debate has little meaning.
"My existence doesn't matter to the government. They don't care if people like me live or die," he said.
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(1184)
-
▼
May
(119)
- 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Lip Butter
- THERABREATH GIVEAWAY WINNER!
- Greenland cold snap linked to Viking disappearance
- Signs of recovery in Japan, debt remains a worry
- Iran oil output 'may drop drastically by 2015'
- 14 dead in Germany as food poisoning crisis grows
- Bangladesh woman cuts off 'attacker's' penis
- Beneath Jerusalem, an underground city takes shape
- Greenpeace climbers occupy Arctic oil rig
- Yemen warplanes bomb Islamists who seized town
- Afghan president seeks to limit NATO airstrikes
- Blast at Japan nuclear plant 'likely gas cylinder'
- Officers disown Gaddafi as peace bid stalls
- Pakistani jets attack Taliban hideouts, kill 17
- Yemen truce ends, stoking worries of civil war
- Obama pledges to stand by tornado-hit town
- Companies look for power way, way up in the sky
- Shuttle Endeavour gone forever from space station
- Germany to close all nuclear plants by 2022
- Science can't design away tornadoes' deadly threat
- Cheetah captured while roaming Abu Dhabi
- Morocco police violently disperse protests
- Villagers say Mladic arrest a surprise
- Barcelona soccer celebrations turn violent
- Suicide bomber attacks Italian base in Afghanistan
- Lawyer: Mladic won't live to see a trial
- Obama exhorts US, allies to bolster Arab spring
- After 4 years, Egypt reopens its border with Gaza
- Germany decides to abandon nuclear power by 2022
- Zuma in Libya as calls grow for Kadhafi exit
- Berlusconi sees local vote as test
- Zelaya: Honduras coup was international conspiracy
- Pakistan to launch offensive in North Waziristan: ...
- NATO chief sees end to Gaddafi's "reign of terror"
- Serbian police detain 180 in pro-Mladic violence
- Truce in Yemen halts week of deadly clashes
- Italian firms look abroad as economy struggles
- Libya rebels applaud G8, stress Kadhafi must go
- Japan PM could face no-confidence motion
- Hollywood star Blanchett under fire over carbon tax
- Yemen president, tribal chief agree to end clashes
- Astronauts pack up on next-to-last shuttle flight
- Chevron to explore shale gas deposits in Bulgaria
- The nation's weather
- Dams power down in the largest US dam removal
- Happy Memorial Day Weekend!
- North Korea frees American detained for half year
- Air India grounds flights amid jet fuel woes
- Aussie student finds universe's 'missing mass'
- G8 pledges $20 billion to foster Arab Spring
- Afghan army salary theft shows fraud widespread
- Bomb kills 8 tribesmen in northwest Pakistan
- Serb court says Mladic fit for genocide trial
- AP Exclusive: Fukushima tsunami plan a single page
- Solomons offer to host Australia migrant centre: r...
- Russia offers to mediate ex-ally Gadhafi's exit
- Faulty readings ahead of 2009 Air France crash
- India's stingy definition of poverty irks critics
- Thailand arrests American for alleged king insult
- Mexico charges 12 prison officials in jailbreak
- Bleak years ahead for Britain: BoE chief economist
- Iraqi police search for killer of anti-Baathist
- Japan moves to protect children as new nuclear lea...
- NASA satellite 'helps find 17 Egypt pyramids'
- Iran hangs 12 people, five of them in public
- CIA to search bin Laden Pakistan compound: report
- Moon may have more water than believed: study
- Leaping roach, 'T-rex' leech among new species
- Malpractice Insurance
- liability insurance website
- Astronauts make history on 4th, final spacewalk
- Severe weather batters 11 states
- Farthest-ever explosion found at edge of cosmos?
- Google unveils smartphone pay service, PayPal sues
- Google takes wraps off pay-by-phone system
- Google turning mobile phone into a wallet
- Rare white kiwi chick hatches at NZ wildlife park
- Civil war looms in Yemen, Saleh urged to quit
- Gunmen kill Iraqi tasked with purging Saddamists
- 7 US troops among 9 NATO dead in Afghanistan
- Are pre-1967 borders indefensible for Israel?
- Israeli officials fret over opening of Gaza border
- Missile issue a sticking point for Obama, Medvedev
- Political turmoil looms over Nepal's peaks
- Clinton, Joint Chiefs chairman press Pakistan
- 29 dead after drug gangs battle in west Mexico
- Serbia arrests Mladic on war crimes charges
- Japan powerbroker Ozawa ready to challenge PM: report
- Clinton in Pakistan, presses for more to quash
- CVS Deals & Bargains 75% OFF Beauty Products!
- Space shuttle crew reinspects ship for damage
- New deep space vehicle to be based on Orion: NASA
- The Science Behind This Terrible Tornado Season
- AP Enterprise: Tornado victims often uninsured
- Eurocontrol: No major ash impact on air traffic
- NASA spacecraft will pluck samples from asteroid
- Pakistan returns U.S. helicopter from bin Laden raid
- 28 dead, 700 flee as gang battles hit west Mexico
- Iran's largest lake turning to salt
- Compressed air turns NZ trucker into human balloon
-
▼
May
(119)